Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner Review

Compare Prices To Find The Lowest Price
48.96 + Shipping ($4.95)
$31.82 First Auto-Ship Order
Free 1-3 Day Shipping Orders $49+
35% Off First Auto-Ship
48.96 + Shipping ($5.95)
$39.17 w/ code PawDiet20
20% Off First AutoShip
Use Code: PawDiet20
47.76 + Shipping (Free)
Free Shipping On Orders $25+
48.96 + Shipping (Free)
Free Shipping On Orders $35+

PawDiet has been helping pet owners since 2015. To fund our efforts, articles may include affiliate links; if you buy something through a link, we may earn a commission.


Review of Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner

According to our data, this Merrick recipe provides complete & balanced nutrition for the maintenance of adult dogs. In other words, this formula is AAFCO approved.

Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for the maintenance of adult dogs.

Review of Ingredients

In our review of Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner, we'll examine all 39 ingredients and highlight the nutritional contribution of each ingredient.

While the first few ingredients typically dominate the recipe's composition, ingredients in small quantities can still have a meaningful impact on the overall nutritional profile of the recipe.

  1. Beef is a high-quality protein source that provides essential amino acids, vitamins, and minerals to support your dog's muscle development and overall health.

  2. Beef broth is a flavorful and hydrating ingredient that adds moisture to your dog's food, making it more appealing and easier to digest. It also provides essential nutrients and can help support overall health and well-being.

  3. Vegetable broth provides not only hydration but also essential nutrients and flavor to make the meal more appealing to dogs.

  4. Potatoes are a good source of vitamins and minerals for dogs, and are also high in fiber which can help keep your dog's digestive system running smoothly.

  5. Carrots are an excellent source of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants for your dog. They're rich in vitamin A, which supports healthy vision and immune function, and also provide fiber to aid in digestion and maintain a healthy weight.

  6. Dried egg product is a highly digestible source of protein that can help to build and maintain your dog's muscle tissue.

  7. Beef liver is a nutrient-rich organ meat that provides essential vitamins and minerals, such as iron, zinc, and B vitamins, which support your dog's overall health and well-being. It is also a good source of high-quality protein, which helps maintain strong muscles and a healthy coat.

  8. Potassium chloride is an essential mineral supplement that helps maintain your dog's electrolyte balance and supports healthy nerve and muscle function.

  9. Zinc sulfate is a source of the essential mineral zinc, which supports your dog's immune system, skin and coat health, and overall growth and development.

  10. Ferrous sulfate is an important source of iron for dogs, a mineral essential for red blood cell production, oxygen transportation, and overall vitality. Adequate iron intake supports your dog's immune system and energy levels.

  11. Copper sulfate is an essential trace mineral that supports various bodily functions in dogs, including immune system health, skin and coat maintenance, and red blood cell production.

  12. Manganese sulfate is a source of manganese, an essential trace mineral that plays a crucial role in maintaining healthy bones, joints, and metabolism in dogs. It also supports the production of collagen, which is vital for healthy skin, coat, and connective tissues.

  13. Potassium iodide is a chemical compound that can be used as a source of iodine in your dog's diet. Iodine is crucial for the proper functioning of your dog's thyroid gland.

  14. Sodium selenite is a form of selenium, a necessary trace mineral that supports immune function and thyroid health in dogs.

  15. Natural flavor is added to dog food to enhance its taste and make it more appealing to your pet. This can help encourage your dog to eat a balanced and nutritious diet, supporting their overall health and well-being.

  16. Potato starch is a carbohydrate source that can provide energy for your dog while being gentle on their digestive system.

  17. Salmon oil is a rich source of Omega-3 fatty acids, which support your dog's skin and coat health, immune system, and cognitive function.

  18. Flaxseed oil is rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, which can help to maintain a healthy skin and coat in dogs, while also supporting heart health and immune function.

  19. Calcium carbonate is a valuable source of calcium, an essential mineral for strong bones and teeth, and for supporting proper muscle function in your dog.

  20. Sodium phosphate is commonly used as a stabilizer in wet pet food products, helping maintain texture and prevent separation of the ingredients.

  21. While salt is a necessary component of a dog's diet, providing essential minerals such as sodium and chloride for proper cellular function, it should be provided in moderation to avoid health issues like hypertension or kidney damage.

  22. Cassia gum is a natural thickening and gelling agent derived from the seeds of the Cassia plant. It helps improve the texture of dog food, making it more appealing to your pet. It is also a source of dietary fiber, which promotes healthy digestion and overall gastrointestinal health.

  23. Fruit juice color is a natural food coloring derived from fruit sources, providing a safe and visually appealing appearance to your dog's food.

  24. Guar gum is a natural thickening agent derived from the guar bean, used to improve the texture of your dog's food. It also serves as a source of soluble fiber, which can help promote healthy digestion and support overall gastrointestinal health.

  25. Xanthan gum is a natural thickening agent used in dog food to improve its texture and consistency. While it doesn't provide direct nutritional benefits, it can make the food more palatable and appealing for your dog.

  26. Cumin is a natural spice that adds flavor to dog food and may provide potential antioxidant benefits to support overall health.

  27. Cinnamon is a natural spice that can help support healthy blood sugar levels and provide antioxidant benefits for your dog's overall health.

  28. Vitamin E supplement is an essential nutrient that helps support your dog's immune system, skin health, and overall wellness.

  29. Niacin, also known as Vitamin B3, is essential for a dog's metabolism and energy production, and supports healthy skin and coat.

  30. Thiamine mononitrate is a form of vitamin B1 that helps support your dog's nervous system function, energy metabolism, and overall health.

  31. Calcium pantothenate is a source of pantothenic acid (vitamin B5) that helps support your dog's energy metabolism and nervous system function.

  32. Pyridoxine hydrochloride is a source of vitamin B6, which is essential for your dog's nervous system function, immune health, and red blood cell production.

  33. Vitamin B12 Supplement is an essential vitamin that helps support brain function and the formation of red blood cells.

  34. Riboflavin supplement is a source of Vitamin B2, which is crucial for your dog's energy production, cell function, and overall growth and development.

  35. Vitamin A Supplement is important for supporting vision, immune function, and skin health in dogs.

  36. Folic acid is a crucial B-vitamin that aids in the synthesis of DNA and supports healthy cell growth. It's essential for maintaining your dog's overall health, particularly during periods of rapid growth.

  37. Vitamin D3 supplement is an essential vitamin that supports bone health, immune function, and overall well-being in dogs. It helps regulate calcium and phosphorus balance in the body, promoting strong and healthy bones.

  38. Biotin is a B-vitamin that's important for maintaining healthy skin, coat, and nails in dogs.

  39. Choline Chloride is an essential nutrient that aids in brain and liver function, muscle movement, and supports healthy metabolic processes.

Review of Guaranteed Analysis

1. Crude Protein (min) of 8.00%: The primary source of protein in this pet food comes from the deboned beef and beef liver. These are high-quality sources of animal protein that contribute to the overall protein content. The dried egg product also contributes to the protein content.

2. Crude Fat (min) of 3.00%: The fat content in this pet food is primarily derived from the beef and beef liver, as well as the salmon oil and flaxseed oil. These ingredients are excellent sources of essential fatty acids, which are necessary for the overall health of pets.

3. Crude Fiber (max) of 1.40%: The fiber content in this pet food comes from the potatoes and carrots. Fiber is essential for healthy digestion in pets.

4. Calories of 934.00 per kg: The caloric content of this pet food is derived from all the ingredients combined but primarily from the deboned beef, potatoes, and carrots, which are high in carbohydrates. The fat content from the salmon and flaxseed oils also contributes significantly to the calorie count.

In addition to these, the pet food also contains a variety of vitamins and minerals. These are derived from both the main ingredients (like the beef and vegetables) and the added supplements (like zinc sulfate, ferrous sulfate, and the vitamin supplements). These nutrients are essential for the overall health and well-being of the pet.

Review of Affordability

According to our data, Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner costs approximately $5.70 per pound. The following table provides our estimate of the monthly cost to feed this recipe exclusively as your dog.

Adult WeightAdult
5 lbs $130.77
10 lbs $219.92
15 lbs $298.08
20 lbs $369.86
30 lbs $501.31
40 lbs $622.03
50 lbs $735.35
60 lbs $843.10
70 lbs $946.43
80 lbs $1046.12
90 lbs $1142.74
100 lbs $1236.70

Estimates are based on average prices and caloric requirements.

Summary of Customer Reviews

Many customers praised the Merrick Grain Free Chunky Pappy's Pot Roast Dinner for its high-quality ingredients and the fact that their dogs loved the taste. Several owners noted that their dogs, who were typically picky eaters, enjoyed this food. The inclusion of real chunks of vegetables was appreciated by many owners, who felt they were providing their pets with a healthy meal.

A few customers, however, expressed concerns about the quality of the product, noting changes in the color and smell of the food. Some reported that their dogs experienced gastric distress after eating it. A few others mentioned that the cans were not filled to the top and that the food was more gravy than meat.

Despite the negative reviews, several customers defended the product, stating that it didn't cause their dogs to have upset stomachs and that their pets loved to eat it. Some owners mentioned that this food was a lifesaver for their dogs who were recovering from surgeries, as it was the only food they would eat.

Owners of dogs with chicken allergies found this product to be a great alternative, as it doesn't contain chicken. They also appreciated the chunky texture of the food, which was preferred by their pets. A few customers did note that they had to pick through the food to ensure their dogs were getting a balanced meal, due to the excessive amount of gravy.

While a few customers were disappointed with the changes in the recipe and quality control issues, many others remained loyal to the Merrick brand. They appreciated the high ratings and trusted the Merrick name. Some customers even commented that the canned food looked and smelled good enough for humans to eat.

A few customers mentioned that they had to cut the chunks into smaller pieces for their small dogs, but their pets still enjoyed the food. Others used it as a topper with their kibble and found that all their dogs, regardless of breed and age, loved it. Several owners expressed their satisfaction with the Merrick line of products, noting the positive impact it had on their dogs' skin and coat.